We All Scream!

A fierce taste-off for the creamiest, most delicious ice cream in the Valley

1. Local Ice 

Minty Mash

Tucked away in a small shopping center, Local Ice is easy to miss. But you shouldn’t. This one-of-a-kind “mom & pop” shop offers an array of decadent flavors and prides itself on using all organic ingredients. It shows. Minty Mash sent our panel of judges over the moon.

JBB: Smooth and refreshing. The creaminess is perfectly balanced with crunchy, chocolaty chunk.

EB: Refreshing and a clever take on the Girl Scout cookie craze.

JB: A modern twist on a classic flavor!

SN: The only downside was that I had to share with the others! I want more!

12747 Ventura Blvd., Studio City, 818-505-8111, local-ice.com



2. Sweet Rose Creamery

Classic Vanilla

This five-store chain has friendly service, a colorful vibe and picnic-style outdoor patio. They also deliver!

JBB: It was #Flawless.

EB: Smooth and crazy good!

JB: It is fresh and light. 

SN: Super-sweet but super-great!

4377 Tujunga Ave., Studio City, 310-260-2663, sweetrosecreamery.com



3. Wanderlust Creamery

Pretzel & Rugbraou

True to its name, all flavors in this shop are completely unique and related to  travel. The flavor our judges selected was inspired by Iceland.

JBB: I was expecting a pretzel taste, but in reality I got coffee with some chunks of pretzel.

EB: Extremely unique flavor. Never had anything like it!

JB: It was probably the creamiest of them all. 

SN: If you don’t like coffee, don’t try this flavor. 

18511 Ventura Blvd., Tarzana, 818-774-9888, wanderlustcreamery.com 



4. Cold Stone Creamery

Fudge Truffle

The granddaddy of Valley ice cream shops, Cold Stone Creamery doles out cones and cups from its spot inside the historic La Reina Theatre.

JBB: It was quite ordinary. Nothing special.

EB: Without the mix-ins, it is very gooey and drab.

JB: Chocolate much? If you’re a chocolate lover, this is the flavor for you.

SN: I love the extremely soft texture.

14622 Ventura Blvd., Sherman Oaks, 818-907-2702, coldstonecreamery.com





Samantha Newman, 18, iLEAD North Hollywood 

Elizabeth Bissell, 17, iLEAD North Hollywood

Jane Borim, 17, iLEAD North Hollywood

Josie Bender Bernstein, 17, LA County High School for the Arts